Author: kktan

 

Starhub – OCBC

Upgrade to HOLD on valuation

  • Hit S$4.02 low recently
  • Yield is more attractive
  • Upgrade to HOLD

 

5% slide post 2Q14 results

StarHub Ltd’s share price has seen a decline of as much as 5% after the telco posted a 6% YoY fall in 2Q14 earnings (still just 0.6% shy of our forecast), as well as lowering its FY14 service revenue guidance from single-digit growth to maintain at about 2013’s level (although it has maintained its service EBITDA margin at 32%). As mentioned in our post-results report, the move came as no surprise to us as we were already poised to pare our estimates should its broadband outlook not improve.

Upgrade to HOLD on valuation ground

Also in our previous report, we said that we would revisit the stock closer to S$4 as the yield would recover back to 5%. And true enough, StarHub recently hit a low of S$4.02. While the stock has recovered somewhat since then, we believe that at current price, its yield is still the most attractive among the three telcos. Although we are retaining our DCF-based fair value at S$3.81, we upgrade our call from Sell to HOLD on valuation ground; this as we also do not expect local interest rates to see a sharp jump in the near- to medium-term.

Prospects remain muted for now

Having said that, we note that the prospects for StarHub remains muted. Besides the still intense competition in the broadband space, the pretty saturated Pay TV space, we believe that the road to lifting mobile ARPUs is likely to be a long one, despite efforts by the telcos to monetize data usage via tiered pricing plans. A recent research by Adobe1 found that as WiFi becomes more available and a lot of mobile plans become more penalizing, people are learning how to switch over to WiFi on their phones. It added that “the telcos through their data plans are essentially teaching people how to avoid mobile data charges.”

SingPost – DBSV

What does postal hike mean?

  • Received approval for 12-30% rate hike across domestic and international mail from 1st Oct 14; first hike in 8 years to mitigate cost increase
  • Annual revenue to improve S$12m-16m but most of it will flow to the bottom line; our FY15F/16F EPS raised 3%/5% conservatively
  • Maintain BUY with revised DCF based (WACC 6.3%, terminal rate 2%) TP of S$2.12. Offers potential return of 25%

Rate hike in response to declining domestic mail volume and rising costs. Since 2008, according to SPOST, labor, and fuel costs have gone up ~30% each, inflation has risen 26% while terminal dues for international mail have risen 43% and will further rise 37% by 2017. About 60% of the domestic mail and ~30% of international outgoing mail is still regulated across which SPOST has raised postal rates by 12-30%, in our estimates.

The hike will be effective from 1st Oct 2014 and SPOST will absorb the cost increase for SMEs in the first year. Based on last year volume, SPOST believes that annual revenue impact could be ~S$16m, however, the actual impact may be ~S$12m due to rebates to SMEs in the first year. Given that mail segment is a high margin business, this should translate into 3%/5% higher FY15F/16F EPS conservatively.

SPOST should command premium valuation for three reasons. Assuming that SPOST makes S$300m worth of acquisitions at 12-15x PER, it may add S$20-25m or 15-20% to our FY16F earnings. Secondly, SPOST is incurring ~S$15m developmental expenses each year, mainly in hiring and training people which could continue for another 2-3 years. We expect SPOST to register healthy growth beyond that. Lastly, higher e-commerce volumes could surprise in FY16F as we have assumed only ~S$50m worth of business from its Chinese e-commerce partner in our forecasts.

SingPost – CIMB

A little help goes a long way

SingPost will revise its domestic and international postage rates effective 1 Oct 2014, the first rate hike since 2006. This will help SingPost to cope with increases in labour costs, fuel prices and international settlement rates for outbound mail and partially offset its continued investments in the postal system. We raise our EPS forecasts by 3-7% to factor in the impact of the new postage rates and our DCF-based target price rises to S$1.96 (7% WACC). We keep our Add call, with the key potential catalysts being: 1) M&A opportunities, and 2) JV with Alibaba.

What Happened

SingPost will revise domestic and international postage rates with effect from 1 Oct 2014. This marks the first rate hike since 2006. Domestic postage rates will increase by 4-20 S cts while international postage rates will rise by 5-25 S cts. The registered article fee for international mail will also be raised from S$2.20 to S$2.50. To help mitigate the impact of the postage rate increase, SingPost will be giving out 10m free stamps to households and charities and offer a 5% rebate to SME franked mail customers for the first year.

What We Think

SingPost has been challenged with a 25-32% rise in labour and fuel costs since its last postage rate hike in 2006 and this new rate hike will help SingPost to cope with cost pressures as mail volumes continue to decline. International settlement rates or terminal dues on outbound mail have risen by 43% due to Singapore being re-classified as a “New Target Country” by the Universal Postal Union in 2012. The rate is expected to climb another 37% by 2017, or an estimated S$35m-40m over the next 2-3 years, which we have previously factored into our forecasts. We estimate that the revised postage rates will add S$8m to revenue in 2HFY15 and S$16m (+1.3-1.6%) from FY16 onwards. On the net profit level, the impact will be more pronounced with a 6-7% upgrade to our estimates from FY16 onwards as the price increase should flow through to the bottomline. This is after accounting for the cost of the 10m free stamps in the first year.

What You Should Do

While this news is a positive, we believe the key potential catalysts for the stock are: 1) M&A opportunities in the e-commerce logistics space, and 2) a JV with Alibaba, which can bring in more e-commerce-related volumes. Our rating remains an Add.

August 2014

Results Announcement

  • 5 Aug 14 : SingPost (Q115) – EPS 1.863ct vs 1.775ct (Q114) ; Div 1.25ct (no change)
  • 5 Aug 14 : Starhub (Q214) – EPS 5.5ct vs 5.85ct (Q213) ; Div 5ct (no change)
  • 11 Aug 14 : HLFin (Q214) – Annualised EPS 12.69ct vs 15.74ct (Q213) ; Div 4ct (no change)
  • 12 Aug 14 : SBSTransit (Q214) – EPS 1.61ct vs 1.02ct (Q213) ; Div 1.25ct vs 0.9ct (1H13)
  • 13 Aug 14 (AM) : STEng (Q214) – EPS 4.28ct vs 4.78ct (Q213) ; Div 4ct vs 3ct (1H13)
  • 13 Aug 14 : ComfortDelgro (Q214) – EPS 3.55ct vs 3.26ct (Q213) ; Div 3.75ct vs 3ct (1H13)
  • 14 Aug 14 (AM) : SingTel (Q115) – EPS 5.24ct vs 6.35ct (Q114)

 

 

STI = 3327.09 (-46.97 for the Month)

Stock

Period

EPS cts

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

PE

Div Breakdown

Hong Leong Fin

FY13 (Dec)

15.85

12.00

$2.750

4.364%

17.35

Interim 4ct ; Final 8ct

SGX

FY14 (Jun)

30

28

$7.280

3.846%

24.27

Q1, Q2, Q3 4ct ; Q4 4ct +12ct

SingPost

FY14 (Mar)

6.746

6.25

$1.725

3.623%

25.57

Q1, Q2, Q3 1.25ct ; Q4 2.5ct

SPH

FY13 (Aug)

27

22.0

$4.150

5.301%

15.37

Interim 7ct ; Final 8ct + Special 7ct

Note : SGX Added from May-14 ; Q4 Variable Div Depends on FY EPS

Aviation Services

Stock

Period

EPS cts

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

PE

Div Breakdown

SATS

FY14 (Mar)

16.10

13.0

$3.030

4.290%

18.82

Interim 5ct ; Final 8ct

SIA Engineering

FY14 (Mar)

23.88

25.0

$4.580

5.459%

19.18

Interim 7ct ; Final 13ct + Special 5ct

ST Engineering

FY13 (Dec)

18.73

15.0

$3.660

4.098%

19.54

Interim 3ct ; Final 4ct + Special 8ct


Note : SIAEC Special Div is Observed to be Non-Recurring (Depends on Excess Cash)

Transport

Stock

Period

EPS cts

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

PE

Div Breakdown

SBSTransit

FY13 (Dec)

3.62

1.80

$1.690

1.065%

46.69

Interim 0.9ct ; Final 0.9ct

ComfortDelGro

FY13 (Dec)

12.43

7.00

$2.510

2.789%

20.19

Interim 3ct ; Final 4ct

SMRT

FY14 (Mar)

4.10

2.20

$1.565

1.406%

38.17

Interim 1.0ct ; Final 1.2ct

TELCO

Stock

Period

EPS cts

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

PE

Div Breakdown

SingTel

FY14 (Mar)

22.92

16.8

$3.890

4.319%

16.97

Interim 6.8ct ; Final 10ct

M1

FY13 (Dec)

17.4

21

$3.800

5.526%

21.84

Interim 6.8ct ; Final 7.1ct + Special 7.1ct

StarHub

FY13 (Dec)

21.50

20

$4.150

4.819%

19.30

Q1 5ct ; Q2 5ct ; Q3 5ct ; Q4 5ct

Infrastructure

Stock

Period

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

NAV

Div Breakdown

SPAus

2H – Mar14

A4.18 (Gross)

$1.640

5.944%

A$0.90

1H14 A4.18ct ; 2H14 A4.18ct

* SPAus DPU in A$. Yield is Calculated Using Latest Exchange Rate (1.1692) fm Yahoo

NOTES :

  • Mkt Price is as on 29-Aug-14
  • ComfortDelgro : Q214 (Jun) –3.5ct
  • ST Engg : 1H14 (Jun) – 4ct
  • SBSTransit : Q214 (Jun) – 1.25ct
  • HLFin : 1H14 (Jun) – 4ct
  • SGX : Q414 (Jun14) – 4ct+ 12ct ; Q314 (Mar14) – 4ct ; Q214 (Dec13) – 4ct ; Q114 (Sep13) – 4ct
  • M1 : 1H14 (Jun) – Interim 7ct
  • SPAus : FY15 Guidance = A8.36ct Gross
  • SPAus : 2H14 (Mar14) – A4.18ct = A1.393ct (Franked) + A2.379ct (Interest – Subject to 10% Tax) + A0.408ct (Capital Returns) ; 1H14 (Sep13) – A4.18ct = A1.393ct (Franked) + A2.396ct (Interest – Subject to 10% Tax) + A0.391ct (Capital Returns)
  • SingTel : 2H14 (Mar14) – Interim 10ct ; 1H14 (Sep13) – Interim 6.8ct
  • StarHub : Q114 (Mar) – 5ct
  • SIAEC : Q414 (Mar14) – Final 13ct + Special 5ct ; Q214 (Sep13) – Interim 7ct
  • SMRT : Q414 (Mar14) – Interim 1.2ct ; Q214 (Sep13) – Interim 1ct
  • ST Engg : Dividend Payout Reduced from 90% to 80% for FY13 & Will Be Further Reduced to 75% from FY14
  • StarHub : FY14 Div Guidance – 5ct/Q
  • SingPost : Q314 (Dec13) – 1.25ct ; Q214 (Sep13) – 1.25ct ; Q114 (Jun13) – 1.25ct
  • SATSvcs : 1H14 (Sep13) – Interim 5ct
  • SPH : 2H13 (Aug) – Final 8ct + Special 7ct ; 1H13 (Feb) – Interim 7ct
  • SingTel : Div Policy – 60% to 75% of Underlying Net Profit

ComfortDelgro – DBSV

Right on schedule

  • 2Q14 in line; 1H forms 49.5% of our FY14F estimates, DPS of 3.75 Scts declared
  • Expect stable growth to continue, aided by recent fare increases, ridership and acquisitions
  • Share price trading at 1.5 std deviation above historical average
  • Maintain HOLD, TP revised marginally to S$2.71

Highlights

2Q14 within expectations. 2Q14 net profit of S$75.7m was 9.9% up from a year ago, as revenue grew by 11.9% y-o-y to S$1.02bn, contributed by all business segments, notably buses (+S$80.3m) and taxis (+S$20m). Operating profit rose by 6.5% y-o-y to S$119.9m, a tad slower than topline due to higher operating expenses (+12.6% y-o-y) arising largely from higher staff costs (+17.3%), fuel & electricity (+25.6%) and premises costs (+26.9%). Operating margins slipped slightly to 11.8%, from 12.4% a year ago. An interim dividend of 3.75 Scts was declared (1H13: 3 Scts), equating to 57.6% payout ratio.

Our View

Stable growth to continue, though y-o-y rate in 2H could be a tad lower. Despite continued cost challenges, we expect management to continue delivering stable growth into 2H14 and FY15/16F, helped by recent fare increases and higher ridership in Singapore, and both organic and inorganic growth overseas. However, we currently expect 2H14 to see a slower y-o-y growth rate compared to that seen in 1H14 (+9.8%), due to a higher base in 2H13 (post-Metroline West acquisition in mid-2013) and lower contribution from Australia due to Sydney Metropolitan Bus Region 4 re-contract in August.

Acquisitions to continue; Blue Mountains Bus soon in the bag. CD recently announced that it had entered into an agreement to acquire Sydney-based Blue Mountain Bus Company for A$26.5m (S$30.8m), subject to regulatory approvals and due diligence. We were not surprised by this bite-sized purchase and view it positively as it will supplement the Group’s overall growth. We expect management to continue on this track to leverage on its strong balance sheet.

Recommendation

Maintain HOLD, TP S$2.71. We like CD for its diverse business and geographical exposure, and steady growth profile coupled with its opportunistic bite-sized acquisitions in areas which are familiar to management. However, we maintain our HOLD recommendation, given limited upside and with its valuation at 19x FY15F PE, which is c.1.5 std deviation above its historical mean. Our forecast is tweaked up marginally by 1.3% on lower minority interests, resulting in a revised TP of S$2.71. We will turn into buyers at c.S$2.40, which implies >10% upside to our TP.