Author: kktan
SIAEC – CIMB
Dividend play
The final dividend of 18 Scts could be the only positive from SIE’s results and the main reason for holding the stock. FY14’s core net profit was below our expectations (at 94% of our forecast), but in line with consensus (at 98% of consensus FY). Revenue growth was slower than expected at 2.7% compared to our forecast 7%. Higher subcontractor costs were also the reasons for SIE’s 3% yoy dip in earnings. We cut our FY15-17 EPS by 7-10% for slower revenue growth. Our target price (still based on blended valuations of 19x P/E & DCF) is reduced accordingly. Our Hold rating is maintained. Rerating catalysts could come from stronger-than-expected revenue and associates/JV growth.
104% dividend payout
SIE declared a final dividend of 18 Scts, bringing its total dividend to 25 Scts, with a total payout of 104%. This is on the back of its net cash of S$536m (+2% yoy). We believe this is helped by higher dividends repatriated from associates and JVs. This keeps the yield reasonably attractive at about 5%.
Slow revenue growth, higher sub-contractors, associates dominate profits
FY14’s revenue grew by 2.7% to S$1.18bn. Line maintenance grew by 3.5% yoy to S$438m, in line with our expectations. However, airframe MRO and fleet management grew by 2.6% yoy to S$744m vs. our expected S$795m. Operating costs were up 4% yoy to S$1.06bn. Staff costs were kept stable at 43% of total op. costs. However, subcontractor costs grew 22% yoy to S$43m (or 16% of total op. costs), possibly due to more outsourced work. Associates/JV remained the largest contributor at 61% of SIE’s PBT (+2% yoy).
Stable outlook
Management said that the demand for MRO services in Asia has continued to grow, but the aviation industry faces competitive challenges which have exerted pressure on MRO rates. Overall, the performance of the group is expected to remain stable, management said.
Limited near-term upside
SIE is trading close to +1 s.d above its 5-year mean. We see limited catalysts in the near-term given the muted revenue and earnings growth.
SIAEC – CIMB
Dividend play
The final dividend of 18 Scts could be the only positive from SIE’s results and the main reason for holding the stock. FY14’s core net profit was below our expectations (at 94% of our forecast), but in line with consensus (at 98% of consensus FY). Revenue growth was slower than expected at 2.7% compared to our forecast 7%. Higher subcontractor costs were also the reasons for SIE’s 3% yoy dip in earnings. We cut our FY15-17 EPS by 7-10% for slower revenue growth. Our target price (still based on blended valuations of 19x P/E & DCF) is reduced accordingly. Our Hold rating is maintained. Rerating catalysts could come from stronger-than-expected revenue and associates/JV growth.
104% dividend payout
SIE declared a final dividend of 18 Scts, bringing its total dividend to 25 Scts, with a total payout of 104%. This is on the back of its net cash of S$536m (+2% yoy). We believe this is helped by higher dividends repatriated from associates and JVs. This keeps the yield reasonably attractive at about 5%.
Slow revenue growth, higher sub-contractors, associates dominate profits
FY14’s revenue grew by 2.7% to S$1.18bn. Line maintenance grew by 3.5% yoy to S$438m, in line with our expectations. However, airframe MRO and fleet management grew by 2.6% yoy to S$744m vs. our expected S$795m. Operating costs were up 4% yoy to S$1.06bn. Staff costs were kept stable at 43% of total op. costs. However, subcontractor costs grew 22% yoy to S$43m (or 16% of total op. costs), possibly due to more outsourced work. Associates/JV remained the largest contributor at 61% of SIE’s PBT (+2% yoy).
Stable outlook
Management said that the demand for MRO services in Asia has continued to grow, but the aviation industry faces competitive challenges which have exerted pressure on MRO rates. Overall, the performance of the group is expected to remain stable, management said.
Limited near-term upside
SIE is trading close to +1 s.d above its 5-year mean. We see limited catalysts in the near-term given the muted revenue and earnings growth.
SMRT – Maybank Kim Eng
Smaller bus loss gives cheer
- Bus operations posted sharp drop in loss but fare-based business still in the red. Fare hike implemented in April will ensure continued improvement in profitability.
- Earnings raised by 17-29% to reflect lower cost estimates.
- Maintain SELL with higher TP of SGD0.65.
What’s New
SMRT reported net profit of SGD16.9m for 4QFY3/14, marginally above our expectations. The boost came from its bus operations, which recorded a sharp reduction in operating loss to SGD4.4m (4QFY3/13: SGD11.9m) in what appeared to be better cost control. Net gearing rose to 60% (FY3/13: 8.2%) as CAPEX more than doubled to SGD652m (FY3/13: SGD251m). Overall, the fare-based business remained in the red for the quarter, chalking up operating loss of SGD3.7m. Full-year DPS was trimmed to 2.2 SGD cts (FY3/13: 2.5 SGD cts), translating to a payout of 54%.
What’s Our View
Following the fare hike last month, we expect SMRT’s fare-based business to continue to improve in the coming quarters. However, as highlighted in our earlier report (note), the estimated annual net benefit of SGD13.2m is insufficient to fully compensate for losses at its fare-based business (FY3/14: SGD25.0m). Therefore, a transition to a sustainable model is still badly needed. We have not factored this into our forecasts. The sharp decline in FY3/17E EPS reflects our expectations for traffic cannibalisation when Stage 2 of the Downtown Line (DTL) opens in 2016. Management will host an analyst briefing today and we expect the discussion to centre on the transition of its fare-based businesses. We raise our FY3/15E/16E/17E earnings forecasts by 28%/17%/29%, albeit off a low base, to reflect lower cost estimates. We reiterate our SELL call but raise our TP to SGD0.65 (from SGD0.60), based on 14x FY3/15E-17E P/E. In our view, it is speculative to conclude that the transition terms for the business model will be favourable.
April 2014
Results Announcement
- 11 Apr 14 : SPH (Q214 – Feb14) – EPS 5ct (todate 11ct) ; Div 7ct
- 14 Apr 14 : M1 (Q114) – EPS 4.6ct
- 24 Apr 14 : HLFin (Q114) – Annualised EPS 13.04ct vs 13.82ct (Q113)
- 9 May 14 : SBSTransit
- 12 May 14 : ComfortDelgro
- 15 May 14 (AM) : Singtel
- 22 May 14 (AM) : SATS
STI = 3264.71 (+76.09 for April)
|
Stock |
Period |
EPS cts |
DPS cts |
Mkt |
Yield |
PE |
Div Breakdown |
|
Hong Leong Fin |
FY13 (Dec) |
15.85 |
12.00 |
$2.750 |
4.364% |
17.35 |
Interim 4ct ; Final 8ct |
|
SingPost |
FY13 (Mar) |
6.435 |
6.25 |
$1.415 |
4.417% |
21.99 |
Q1, Q2, Q3 1.25ct ; Q4 2.5ct |
|
SPH |
FY13 (Aug) |
27 |
22.0 |
$4.190 |
5.251% |
15.52 |
Interim 7ct ; Final 8ct + Special 7ct |
Aviation Services
|
Stock |
Period |
EPS cts |
DPS cts |
Mkt |
Yield |
PE |
Div Breakdown |
|
SATS |
FY13 (Mar) |
16.60 |
15.0 |
$3.170 |
4.732% |
19.10 |
Interim 5ct ; Final 6ct + Special 4ct |
|
SIA Engineering |
FY13 (Mar) |
24.51 |
22.0 |
$4.790 |
4.593% |
19.54 |
Interim 7ct ; Final 15ct |
|
ST Engineering |
FY13 (Dec) |
18.73 |
15.0 |
$3.820 |
3.927% |
20.40 |
Interim 3ct ; Final 4ct + Special 8ct |
Note : SATS Special Div is Observed to be Non-Recurring
Transport
|
Stock |
Period |
EPS cts |
DPS cts |
Mkt |
Yield |
PE |
Div Breakdown |
|
SBSTransit |
FY13 (Dec) |
3.62 |
1.80 |
$1.250 |
1.440% |
34.53 |
Interim 0.9ct ; Final 0.9ct |
|
ComfortDelGro |
FY13 (Dec) |
12.43 |
7.00 |
$2.120 |
3.302% |
17.06 |
Interim 3ct ; Final 4ct |
|
SMRT |
FY13 (Mar) |
5.5 |
2.50 |
$1.220 |
2.049% |
22.18 |
Interim 1.5ct ; Final 1.0ct |
TELCO
|
Stock |
Period |
EPS cts |
DPS cts |
Mkt |
Yield |
PE |
Div Breakdown |
|
SingTel |
FY13 (Mar) |
22.02 |
16.8 |
$3.830 |
4.386% |
17.39 |
Interim 6.8ct ; Final 10ct |
|
M1 |
FY13 (Dec) |
17.4 |
21 |
$3.360 |
6.250% |
19.31 |
Interim 6.8ct ; Final 7.1ct + Special 7.1ct |
|
StarHub |
FY13 (Dec) |
21.50 |
20 |
$4.150 |
4.819% |
19.30 |
Q1 5ct ; Q2 5ct ; Q3 5ct ; Q4 5ct |
Infrastructure
|
Stock |
Period |
DPS cts |
Mkt |
Yield |
NAV |
Div Breakdown |
|
SPAus |
1H – Sep13 |
A4.18 (Gross) |
$1.615 |
6.030% |
A$0.92 |
1H14 A4.18ct ; 2H13 A4.1ct |
* SPAus DPU in A$. Yield is Calculated Using Latest Exchange Rate (1.1648) fm Yahoo
NOTES :
- Mkt Price is as on 30-Apr-14
- HLFin : 2H13 (Dec) – 8ct ; 1H13 (Jun) – 4ct
- ST Engg : 2H13 (Dec) – 4ct (Final) + 8ct (Special) ; 1H13 (Jun) – 3ct
- MIIF : 2H13 (Dec) –0.7ct
- ComfortDelgro : Q413 (Dec) –4ct ; Q213 (Jun) –3ct
- SBSTransit : Q413 (Dec) – 0.9ct ; Q213 (Jun) – 0.9ct
- StarHub : Q413 (Dec) – 5ct ; Q313 (Sep) – 5ct ; Q213 (Jun) – 5ct ; Q113 (Mar) – 5ct
- StarHub : FY14 Div Guidance – 5ct/Q
- SingPost : Q314 (Dec13) – 1.25ct ; Q214 (Sep13) – 1.25ct ; Q114 (Jun13) – 1.25ct
- SPAus : 2H13 (Mar13) – A4.1ct = A1.367ct (Franked) + A2.649ct (Interest) + A0.084ct (Capital Returns) ; 1H14 (Sep13) – A4.18ct = A1.393ct (Franked) + A2.396ct (Interest) + A0.391ct (Capital Returns)
- SingTel : 1H14 (Sep13) – Interim 6.8ct
- SIAEC : Q214 (Sep13) – Interim 7ct
- SATSvcs : 1H14 (Sep13) – Interim 5ct
- SMRT : Q214 (Sep13) – Interim 1ct
- SPH : 2H13 (Aug) – Final 8ct + Special 7ct ; 1H13 (Feb) – Interim 7ct
- MIIF : FY13 Guidance 2H13 (Dec) –0.8ct (Final) ; CXP Return of Capital = 9.7ct
- M1 : 1H13 (Jun) – Interim 6.8ct
- MIIF : FY13 Guidance 1H13 (Jun) –0.7ct ; 2H13 (Dec) – 1.2ct (Final) ; APTT IPO Entitlement / 1000 MIIF Shares (Estimate) = 457 APTT Shares or $443.29
- SPAus : FY14 Guidance = A8.36ct
- SingTel : Div Policy – 60% to 75% of Underlying Net Profit
SMRT – Maybank Kim Eng
Share price surged… avoid the hype
- Share price surged 18.5% to its highest since 10 Dec.
- While a favourable transition of its business model is likely, this surge is speculative in the absence of announcements by the regulators or operators.
- Maintain Sell with TP of SGD0.60, based on 14x average EPS for FY3/14-16.
SMRT’s share price surged…
SMRT’s share price surged by 18.5% to close at its highest in almost five months, stoking speculations of impending corporate developments. In response to this, the stock exchange’s surveillance department has issued a query to which SMRT has replied that they are not aware of any news that has caused the price surge.
… Avoid the hype; maintain SELL
In our view, there are two possible corporate developments:
1) Nationalisation of SMRT via a general offer. This allows SMRT to run as a non-profit organisation. However, we think this is unlikely as Singapore’s Transport Minister had previously argued against nationalisation on ground that nationalisation may lead to higher fares and become a burden on taxpayers.
2) Favourable transition to new business model for fare-based business. This is a more likely scenario. SMRT’s core fare-based business suffered an operating loss of SGD32m in 2013 and is expected to remain a key drag to profitability in the future. While a change is imminent, it is highly speculative to conclude that the terms will be favourable to shareholders. In particular, we are concerned over the treatment of the asset purchase obligations under the old rail financing regime (note). In the absence of material announcements, we advise investors to stay cautious. SMRT trades at a rich valuation of 30x FY3/15E P/E. Maintain SELL with TP of SGD0.60.