SATS – Lim and Tan

Noteworthy Share Transaction

• The airline catering / ground handling company, made its first buy-back of its own shares, buying 300,000 shares yesterday at $2.56 each.

• The stock has been under much pressure, dropping from $2.96 on Jan 19th to the $2.53 low two Fridays ago.

• The surge in crude oil, the disasters in Japan have all taken a toll on the airline related sector.

• We would upgrade the stock from Neutral to BUY.

(We have all along preferred SIA Engineering, a former sister company within the SIA Group.)

• Based on the 13 cents dividend paid in respect of ye Mar 2010, yield is 5.1%. Net profit rose 4% in the 9 months to Dec ’10, putting stock on 15x trailing PE.

March 2011

Results Announcement

  • 13 Apr 11 : SPH (Q211)
  • 4 May 11 : StarHub (Q111)

 

STI = 3105.85 (+10.53)

Stock

Period

EPS cts

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

PE

Div Breakdown

SPH

FY10 (Aug)

31

27

$3.94

6.853%

12.71

Interim 7ct ; Final 9ct + 11ct (Special)

SingPost

FY10 (Mar)

8.563

6.25

$1.16

5.388%

13.55

Q1, Q2, Q3 1.25ct ; Q4 2.5ct

STI ETF

Dec-10

3.5

$3.14

2.229%

Dec10 3.5ct ; Jun10 3ct

SATS

FY10 (Mar)

16.7

13

$2.51

5.179%

15.03

Final 8ct ; Interim 5ct

ST Engg

FY10 (Dec)

16.21

14.55

$3.26

4.463%

20.11

Final 4ct + 7.55ct (Special) ; Interim 3ct

Transport

Stock

Period

EPS cts

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

PE

Div Breakdown

SBSTransit

FY10 (Dec)

17.63

8.80

$1.99

4.422%

11.29

Interim 4.5ct ; Final 4.3ct

ComfortDelGro

FY10 (Dec)

10.95

5.50

$1.56

3.526%

14.25

Interim 2.7ct ; Final 2.8ct

SMRT

FY10 (Mar)

10.7

8.5

$1.89

4.497%

17.66

Interim 1.75ct ; Final 6.75ct

TELCO

Stock

Period

EPS cts

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

PE

Div Breakdown

SingTel

FY10 (Mar)

24.55

14.2

$3.02

4.702%

12.30

Interim 6.2ct ; Final 8ct

M1

FY10 (Dec)

17.5

17.5

$2.41

7.261%

13.77

Interim 6.3ct ; Final 7.7ct + Special 3.5ct

StarHub

FY10 (Dec)

15.34

20

$2.70

7.407%

17.60

Q1 5ct ; Q2 5ct ; Q3 5ct ; Q4 5ct

Funds / Infrastructure

Stock

Period

DPS cts

Mkt

Yield

NAV

Div Breakdown

SPAus

2H10 (Mar-10)

A4.0 (Gross)

$1.140

9.145%

A$0.91

2H10 A4.0ct ; 1H10 A4.0ct

MIIF

2H – Dec10

1.50

$0.615

4.878%

$0.83

2H10 1.5ct ; 1H10 1.5ct

* SPAus DPU in A$. Yield is Calculated Using Latest Exchange Rate (1.3032) fm Yahoo

NOTES :

  • Mkt Price is as on 31-Mar-11
  • MIIF : 2H10 (Dec) – 1.5ct ; 1H10 (Jun) – 1.5ct
  • ST Engg : 2H10 (Dec) – 4ct (Final) + 7.55ct (Special) ; 1H10 (Jun) – 3ct
  • ComfortDelgro : Q410 (Dec) – 2.8ct ; Q210 (Jun) – 2.7ct
  • SBSTransit : Q410 (Dec) – 4.3ct ; Q210 (Jun) – 4.5ct
  • StarHub : FY11 Div Guidance – 5ct/Q
  • StarHub : Q410 (Dec) – 5ct ; Q310 (Sep) – 5ct ; Q210 (Jun) – 5ct ; Q110 (Mar) – 5ct
  • SingPost : Q311 (Dec10) – 1.25ct ; Q211 (Sep10) – 1.25ct ; Q111 (Jun10) – 1.25ct
  • M1 : 2H10 (Dec) – Final 7.7ct + Special 3.5ct ; 1H10 (Jun) – Interim 6.3ct
  • SingTel : 1H11 (Sep10) – Interim 6.8ct
  • SPAus : 1H11 (Sep10) – A4ct (before tax) / A3.7772ct (after tax) ; 2H10 (Mar10) – A4ct (before tax) / A3.7739ct (after tax)
  • SATSvcs : Q211 (Sep10) – Interim 5ct
  • SMRT : Q211 (Sep10) – Interim 1.75ct
  • SPH : 2H10 (Aug) – 20ct ; 1H10 (Feb) – 7ct

 

SATS – OCBC

Increasingly attractive risk-reward proposition

Price weakness presents attractive entry level. Shares of SATS Ltd (SATS) have fallen by 9% (vs. STI -4%) since the group released its 3Q11 results, weighed down by concerns over food price inflation and the threat of heightened competition arising from the entry of a third ground handler at Changi Airport. We believe that these risks have been adequately priced in with the stock trading close to its 52-week low. Not withstanding potential cost pressure stemming from these factors, we believe that investors may have overlooked the positive impact of aviation demand recovery on SATS’ outlook. We forecast a 5.5% growth in FY11 earnings and a further 8.0% improvement in FY12 profits, driven by regional air traffic growth.

Aviation recovery, tourism growth to buoy performance. As a recap, SATS recorded a 6.6% YoY growth in 9M11 revenue to S$1.2b, while net profit increased by 4.5% YoY to S$140.7m. The group’s growth has been driven by higher aviation and non-aviation revenue, further fuelled by improved contributions from overseas associates. Going forward, revenue growth should be supported by the continued recovery of the aviation sector, albeit at a moderating pace. The ICAO (International Civil Aviation Organization) forecasts approximately an 8% growth in Asia Pacific’s air traffic in 2011 and 2012 following an 11% jump in 2010. An additional catalyst could stem from Singapore’s robust tourism landscape, which in 2010 saw a 20% jump in visitor arrivals thanks in part to the opening of the two Integrated Resorts. Singapore’s robust tourism landscape could serve as a meaningful growth driver given that the country accounts for 75% of SATS’ revenue.

Improving risk-reward proposition. We anticipate near term risks stemming from (i) food price inflation, which may elevate operating costs, and (ii) possible knee-jerk reaction upon the announcement of a third ground handler. Nevertheless, SATS has pass-through cost structures in place, which we believe should partially relief higher raw material costs in the medium term. Meanwhile, we believe that the market has priced in the threat of a third ground handler, and an official announcement could possibly lift the share price overhang. Furthermore, we understand that the third license may pertain to a specific segment of services (eg. technical ramp handling) rather than the entire suite of ground handling services. Such a scenario favours SATS as it would lessen the scope of competition. We maintain our BUY rating on SATS and revise our fair value estimate to S$2.87 (previously S$3.31) as we fine-tuned our model. Dividend yield is attractive at 5.5%.

SPH – BT

The Clementi Mall is fully leased

THE Clementi Mall, in which Singapore Press Holdings has a 60 per cent stake, is fully leased ahead of project completion – with about half of its tenants opening for business today and the remaining tenants following soon after.

All the shops at Basement 1 and Level 1, including anchor tenant FairPrice Finest, have been open for business since January, after the six-storey retail development in Clementi town centre obtained its first temporary occupancy permit.

Anchor tenants BHG and Foodfare foodcourt will open their doors today and tomorrow respectively. Other anchor tenants, such as Best Denki and Popular Bookstore, will open in mid-April.

Clementi Public Library is scheduled to open on April 23.

The bridge which links the mall directly to the Clementi MRT station on Level 3 will open to the public today, allowing shoppers access via the station during trading hours.

Fashion and accessories labels such as Charles & Keith, Cache Cache, Cotton On, Denizen, Giordano, Skechers and Samuel & Kevin can be found on Level 3.

Lifestyle, sports and electrical shops such as Aussino, Arena, Challenger and World Of Sports will be on Level 4.

Family and kids brands such as Chateau De Sable, Kiddy Palace and Mini Princess will be on Level 5. The Clementi public library and Popular Bookstore will also be located on this level.

The development, owned by CM Domain, has about 190,000 square feet of retail space, including a basement shopping level and a basement carpark with about 160 parking lots.

CM Domain, in which SPH owns a 60 per cent stake through subsidiary Times Properties, won the tender for the 99-year leasehold property with its bid price of $541.9 million in November 2009.

The other joint owners of CM Domain are NTUC Income Insurance Co-operative Limited (20 per cent) and NTUC FairPrice Co-operative Limited (20 per cent).


 

ComfortDelgro – Phillip

Latent potential with overseas venture

Strong potential with CDG’s venture overseas

Limited exposure to energy price increase

NEL should continue to perform well; stronger than expected overseas performance is the wild card

We revised our PATMI estimates upwards for FY11E by 5.6% and introduce FY12/13E estimates

Maintain Buy following a change of analyst with revised target price of S$2.01

INVESTMENT MERITS:

Global diversification. We believe that CDG’s efforts to grow its businesses beyond Singapore could lead to significant earnings growth in the future. It also reduces their dependency on the Singapore market, which has a limited scope for land transport growth.

NEL likely to do well. CDG’s rail system serves the populous areas in the North-East of Singapore. We expect continued population growth to increase ridership for their rail business.

Limited exposure to energy price increase. Exposure to energy cost is a typical concern of investing into transportation businesses. However, we believe that CDG is less exposed to potential energy price increase than its peers due to their diversified businesses and varied business models.

Licenses & Operating rights protect competitive position. We observed sustainable profitability at some of CDG’s overseas subsidiaries, which we believe could be attributable to a protected competitive position.

KEY CHALLENGES:

Singapore Bus. We expect CDG’s bus business to be affected by the growth of rail network in Singapore. Plans to extend Singapore’s rail network to 270km by 2020 is likely to result in significant cannibalization of ridership from bus operations. With a 75% market share, we foresee long term challenges for CDG’s public bus operations in Singapore. CCL’s full opening at the end of 2011 will be the near term headwind for the company.

M & A. CDG aims to derive 70% of its revenue from overseas in the long run. While we are supportive of its venture overseas, we believe that there are inherent challenges and risks in growing their businesses overseas.

Key Risks. Regulatory; Forex; M & A.

Valuation. The current market price values the stock at 14X T12M EPS, which is at the lower end of the stock’s historical trading range. Due to our expectations of robust growth in the near future, we opine that the stock deserves an above average valuation. We used a blended valuation model of DCF (COE: 8.2%, terminal g: 1%) and P/E (17X FY11e PATMI) to arrive at our target price of S$2.01. With an upside of 33.4% to the last trading price, we maintain our Buy call on CDG with a revised target price.